Rulings Repository

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Thu Apr 17, 2014 7:16 am

Welcome to the Rulings Repository. As of right now I'd like to limit any posting here to the Moderators and myself, to avoid having any non-ruling related discussion.

This list is by no means complete, and probably never will be(it's also disorganized right now... but I can and will fix that later). If you can think of an important ruling that is not on this list, please let me know here. I'd also ask that the current Moderators post a copy of their rulings here so I can edit them into this thread(though by no means can I compel them to do so

).

Discussion can be held here: viewtopic.php?f=9&t=292484

1: Rulings on Passed Resolutions
2: Category
3: Committee
4: Duplication and Contradiction
5: "Human" Rights
6: Meta-gaming
7: Optionality and Ideological Bans
8: Plagiarism and Branding
9: Proposal Language
10: Repeals, House of Cards, and Blockers
11: The WA Itself
12: Moderation
13: Uncategorized

Raw Alphabetized List:

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Thu Apr 17, 2014 7:16 am

By Resolution Number

Resolution #2 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=1309097#p1309097
Resolution #2 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=1309097#p1309097
Resolution #2 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3641952#p3641952
Resolution #2 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Resolution #2 - Discussion viewtopic.php?p=19353563#p19353563
Resolution #2 - Legislation of Ideological Bans viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Resolution #4 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788
Resolution #9 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=9309515#p9309515
Resolution #10 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=5155740#p5155740
Resolution #14 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3641952#p3641952
Resolution #15 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=8751349#p8751349
Resolution #15 - Repealing without NatSov (etc.) arguments viewtopic.php?p=5980630#p5980630
Resolution #15 - Repealing without NatSov (etc.) arguments viewtopic.php?p=8511129#p8511129
Resolution #16 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788
Resolution #17 - Funding the GA viewtopic.php?p=14853242#p14853242
Resolution #20 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637
Resolution #22 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=8518876#p8518876
Resolution #23 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788
Resolution #27 - Freedom of Religion viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Resolution #29 - Abortion Discussion viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Resolution #29 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=18413537#p18413537
Resolution #29 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Resolution #29 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Resolution #29 - Freedom of Religion viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Resolution #30 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=8030152#p8030152
Resolution #30 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3643321#p3643321
Resolution #30 - Freedom of Religion viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Resolution #35 - Abortion Discussion viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Resolution #35 - Compelling Practical Purpose elaboration viewtopic.php?p=4503499#p4503499
Resolution #35 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=5404565#p5404565
Resolution #35 - Discussion on potential Duplication/Contradiction viewtopic.php?p=4250570#p4250570
Resolution #35 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3643321#p3643321
Resolution #35 - Duplication (declared "minor," legal) viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Resolution #35 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=3473941#p3473941
Resolution #35 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=5414119#p5414119
Resolution #35 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=19396566#p19396566
Resolution #35 - Duplication (denied) [filling holes in existing legislation] viewtopic.php?p=5414119#p5414119
Resolution #35 - Duplication (denied) [filling holes in existing legislation] viewtopic.php?p=19396566#p19396566
Resolution #35 - Freedom of Religion viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Resolution #35 - Religious Discrimination viewtopic.php?p=5242450#p5242450
Resolution #37 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=1419738#p1419738
Resolution #41 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=7026073#p7026073
Resolution #44 [REPEALED] - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=4489278#p4489278
Resolution #47 - category/strength discussion viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612
Resolution #54 - Ideological ban (denied) viewtopic.php?p=263586#p263586
Resolution #62 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637
Resolution #63 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3510890#p3510890
Resolution #66 - Potential Duplication (no ruling) viewtopic.php?p=17465521#p17465521
Resolution #67 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=1419738#p1419738
Resolution #68 - Contradiction (analysis) viewtopic.php?f=16&t=20913
Resolution #68 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=799613#p799613
Resolution #68 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=3325938#p3325938
Resolution #68 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=7246191#p7246191
Resolution #68 - Contradiction (denied) viewtopic.php?p=19116711#p19116711
Resolution #68 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=6159542#p6159542
Resolution #76 - Branding (legal) viewtopic.php?p=2816670#p2816670
Resolution #76 - Contradiction (potential) viewtopic.php?p=1309097#p1309097
Resolution #80 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=8731205#p8731205
Resolution #82 - Duplication (declared "minor," legal) viewtopic.php?p=1932711#p1932711
Resolution #87 - Citing previous puppet of author's as co-author viewtopic.php?p=1744192#p1744192
Resolution #97 - Duplication (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=5904121#p5904121
Resolution #99 - Ruling on various topics (pre-vote) viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637
Resolution #102 - Big Fat WA Committee viewtopic.php?p=15390194#p15390194
Resolution #104 - Branding (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=2816670#p2816670
Resolution #114 - Abortion Discussion viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Resolution #114 - Proposals that are non-species specific viewtopic.php?p=4163245#p4163245
Resolution #122 - Joke Proposal (denied) viewtopic.php?p=3989224#p3989224
Resolution #124 - Medical Marijuana (category) viewtopic.php?p=4002815#p4002815
Resolution #128 - Abortion Discussion viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Resolution #128 - Analysis viewtopic.php?p=8621656#p8621656
Resolution #128 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Resolution #128 - Duplication/Amendment (denied) viewtopic.php?p=18973033#p18973033
Resolution #141 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=18413537#p18413537
Resolution #149 - Human Rights strength challenge (denied) viewtopic.php?p=4711929#p4711929
Resolution #156 - Ideological ban (denied) viewtopic.php?p=4521974#p4521974
Resolution #168 - Category/strength discussion viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612
Resolution #179 - Contradiction (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=20086168#p20086168
Resolution #195 - "Honest Mistakes" in Repeal (denied) viewtopic.php?p=9081425#p9081425
Resolution #205 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Resolution #221 - Committee only Prop (mod confirmation via Auralia a few posts later) viewtopic.php?p=10962542#p10962542
Resolution #237 - Strength of Human Rights category viewtopic.php?p=12421045#p12421045
Resolution #248 - Ideological Ban (denied) viewtopic.php?p=13470364#p13470364
Resolution #248 - Social Justice v. Political Stability viewtopic.php?p=13470364#p13470364
Resolution #266 - Illegal repeal attempt on definition (i.e. NatSov) grounds viewtopic.php?p=17028873#p17028873
Resolution #266 - Incorrect strength (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=11512126#p11512126
Resolution #279 - Duplication (denied) viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Resolution #286 - Proposal Title challenge (denied) viewtopic.php?p=18848108#p18848108
Resolution #287 - Just a Committee challenge (denied) viewtopic.php?p=19061145#p19061145
Resolution #288 - Category discussion viewtopic.php?p=19194061#p19194061[/spoiler]

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Thu Apr 17, 2014 9:31 am

Category:

Category Discussion - Free Trade, Global Disarmament, Political Stability, Social Justice, Moral Decency viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612
Category Discussion - Gambling & Gun Control are Either/Or Categories viewtopic.php?p=3989224#p3989224
Category Discussion - Gun Control viewtopic.php?p=19116711#p19116711
Category Discussion - Human Rights affects non-Human species viewtopic.php?p=5414119#p5414119
Category Discussion - Human Rights is not a catch-all category viewtopic.php?p=4711929#p4711929
Category Discussion - Human Rights v. Moral Decency viewtopic.php?p=4427200#p4427200
Category Discussion - International Security viewtopic.php?p=2877431#p2877431
Category Discussion - Medical Marijuana: Resolution #124 viewtopic.php?p=4002815#p4002815
Category Discussion - mild Strength proposals viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612
Category Discussion - Moral Decency v. Healthcare viewtopic.php?p=4163245#p4163245
Category Discussion - Political Stability viewtopic.php?p=1309803#p1309803
Category Discussion - Recreational Drug Use and Medical Marijuana viewtopic.php?p=4002815#p4002815
Category Discussion - Resolution #288 viewtopic.php?p=19194061#p19194061
Category Discussion - Social Justice (v. Healthcare) viewtopic.php?p=19194061#p19194061
Category Discussion - Social Justice v. Political Stability viewtopic.php?p=13470364#p13470364
Category Discussions - Free Trade (mild versus significant strength) viewtopic.php?p=11512126#p11512126
Category Discussions - Global Disarmament versus Human Rights viewtopic.php?p=9795292#p9795292
Category Discussions - Tort Reform v. Social Justice viewtopic.php?p=7898028#p7898028
Category Discussions - Social Justice v. Political Stability Resolultion #248 viewtopic.php?p=13470364#p13470364

Category/Strength Discussion - Resolution #47 viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612
Category/Strength Discussion - Resolution #168 viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612

Category Strength - Decision-based categories & All Industries viewtopic.php?p=5747926#p5747926
Category Strength - Furtherment of Democracy prop viewtopic.php?p=19396566#p19396566
Category Strength - Gambling viewtopic.php?p=4072318#p4072318
Category Strength - Human Rights viewtopic.php?p=12421045#p12421045
Category Strength - Human Rights viewtopic.php?p=18973033#p18973033
Category Strength - Vague proposals are not significant viewtopic.php?p=3643321#p3643321
Category Strength(Insufficient) (affirmative) - Resolution #266 - viewtopic.php?p=11512126#p11512126

Write to the Category recommendation viewtopic.php?p=19136612#p19136612

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:38 am

Committee:

Committee Violation - composition of committees viewtopic.php?p=5155740#p5155740

Just a Committee (affirmative) - viewtopic.php?p=5242450#p5242450
Just a Committee (affirmative) - viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Just a Committee (affirmative) (mod confirmation via Auralia a few posts later) - Resolution #221 - viewtopic.php?p=10962542#p10962542
Just a Committee (affirmative) - Explaination viewtopic.php?p=20223291#p20223291
Just a Committee (denied) - viewtopic.php?p=19061145#p19061145
Just a Committee (denied) - Resolution #287 viewtopic.php?p=19061145#p19061145

Expansion of Extant Committees (legal) - viewtopic.php?p=17465521#p17465521

Big Fat WA Committee - Resolution #102 viewtopic.php?p=15390194#p15390194

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:42 am

Duplication and Contradiction:

Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #15 viewtopic.php?p=8751349#p8751349
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #23 viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #30 viewtopic.php?p=3643321#p3643321
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=3643321#p3643321
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #44[REPEALED] viewtopic.php?p=4489278#p4489278
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #62 viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=6159542#p6159542
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #80 viewtopic.php?p=8731205#p8731205
Duplication (affirmative) - Resolution #97 viewtopic.php?p=5904121#p5904121
Duplication (declared "minor," legal) - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Duplication (declared "minor," legal) - Resolution #82 viewtopic.php?p=1932711#p1932711
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #4 viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #16 viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=3473941#p3473941
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=5414119#p5414119
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=19396566#p19396566
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #205 viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Duplication (denied) - Resolution #279 viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Duplication (denied) - [filling holes in existing legislation] Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=5414119#p5414119
Duplication (denied) - [filling holes in existing legislation] Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=19396566#p19396566
Duplication - Abortion (Discussion) viewtopic.php?p=4427200#p4427200
Duplication - Abortion (lots of passed resolutions referenced) viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Duplication - minor overlap with an existing resolution is legal viewtopic.php?p=1932711#p1932711
Duplication - minor overlap with a existing resolution is legal viewtopic.php?p=18656344#p18656344
Duplication/Amendment (denied) - Resolution #128 viewtopic.php?p=18973033#p18973033

Discussion on potential Duplication/Contradiction - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=4250570#p4250570

Potential Duplication (no ruling) - Resolution #66 viewtopic.php?p=17465521#p17465521

Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #2 viewtopic.php?p=3641952#p3641952
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #2 viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #10 viewtopic.php?p=5155740#p5155740
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #14 viewtopic.php?p=3641952#p3641952
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #29 viewtopic.php?p=18413537#p18413537
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #29 viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #29 viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #30 viewtopic.php?p=8030152#p8030152
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #63 viewtopic.php?p=3510890#p3510890
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #128 viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #141 viewtopic.php?p=18413537#p18413537
Contradiction (affirmative) - Resolution #179 viewtopic.php?p=20086168#p20086168
Contradiction (analysis) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?f=16&t=20913
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #9 viewtopic.php?p=9309515#p9309515
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #20 viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #22 viewtopic.php?p=8518876#p8518876
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #22 viewtopic.php?p=8518876#p8518876
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=5404565#p5404565
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #37 viewtopic.php?p=1419738#p1419738
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #41 viewtopic.php?p=7026073#p7026073
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #67 viewtopic.php?p=1419738#p1419738
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=799613#p799613
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=3325938#p3325938
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=7246191#p7246191
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=19116711#p19116711
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=19780210#p19780210
Contradiction (denied) - Resolution #68 viewtopic.php?p=19833856#p19833856
Contradiction (potential) - Resolution #76 viewtopic.php?p=1309097#p1309097

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:47 am

"Human" Rights:

Species-wank viewtopic.php?p=4250570#p4250570
Strength of Human Rights category - Resolution #237 viewtopic.php?p=12421045#p12421045
Human Rights: Strength Challenge (denied) Resolution #149 viewtopic.php?p=4711929#p4711929

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:50 am

Meta-gaming:

Game Mechanics - expanding the scope of the SC viewtopic.php?p=5155740#p5155740
Game Mechanics - resolutions affect WA nations, not WA player RP viewtopic.php?p=15390194#p15390194
Game Mechanics - Courts are not the same as a WA Police viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637
Game Mechanics - WA Police (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=3641952#p3641952

Language - Commentary/Debates must be in English; other languages allowed if spoilered viewtopic.php?p=8835445#p8835445

Meta-Gaming - (Affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=1467119#p1467119
Meta-Gaming - Affecting non-WA Nations (denied) viewtopic.php?p=3325938#p3325938
Meta-Gaming - Affecting specific WA-nations differently than others viewtopic.php?p=1053929#p1053929
Meta-Gaming - Forced Roleplay viewtopic.php?p=4489278#p4489278
Meta-Gaming - Mentioning non-WA Nations (cautionary tale) viewtopic.php?p=1460150#p1460150
Meta-Gaming - referencing the Security Council in a resolution (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=14854891#p14854891
Meta-Gaming - referencing WA nations and puppets (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=6581639#p6581639
Meta-Gaming - Resolutions cannot affect WA gnomes viewtopic.php?p=12511711#p12511711
Meta-Gaming - Resolutions go into effect immediately upon passage viewtopic.php?p=1441077#p1441077
Meta-Gaming - Trying to enforce compliance viewtopic.php?p=6177108#p6177108

Multiverse - writing to potentially include all WA nations viewtopic.php?p=3510890#p3510890
Multiverse- writing to potentially include all WA nation species viewtopic.php?p=4250570#p4250570

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:52 am

Optionality and Ideological Bans:

Optionality Rule - challenge (denied) viewtopic.php?p=263586#p263586
Optionality Rule - excluding certain classes of beings (not recommended) viewtopic.php?p=4216369#p4216369
Optionality Rule - further elaboration viewtopic.php?p=5984216#p5984216

Ideological Ban challenge (affirmative) - viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Ideological Ban challenge (denied) - viewtopic.php?p=263586#p263586
Ideological Ban challenge (denied) - viewtopic.php?p=1309097#p1309097
Ideological Ban challenge (denied) - viewtopic.php?p=4521974#p4521974
Ideological Ban challenge (denied) - Resolution #54 viewtopic.php?p=263586#p263586
Ideological Ban challenge (denied) - Resolution #156 viewtopic.php?p=4521974#p4521974
Ideological Ban challenge (denied) - Resolution #248 viewtopic.php?p=13470364#p13470364

Ideological Ban - Corruption is not an ideology viewtopic.php?p=13470364#p13470364

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:53 am

Plagiarism and Branding:

Plagiarism - proposal based largely on another player's draft (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=5727758#p5727758
Plagiarism - using a proposal text by a former nation (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=18142148#p18142148
Plagiarism - resubmitting one's own (now repealed) proposal text (legal) viewtopic.php?p=9207661#p9207661
Plagiarism - resubmitting one's own draft (from a previous puppet) legal with noted co-author credit viewtopic.php?p=1744192#p1744192

May list author (if different from submitting nation) at end of proposal text viewtopic.php?f=16&p=7932896#p7932896
Citing previous puppet of author's as co-author - Resolution #87 viewtopic.php?p=1744192#p1744192

Branding (illegal) - Resolution #104 viewtopic.php?p=2816670#p2816670
Branding (legal) - Resolution #76 viewtopic.php?p=2816670#p2816670
Branding - Acronyms and Acrostics that may cause confusion with other NS acronyms are illegal viewtopic.php?p=7647591#p7647591
Branding - One co-author is allowed viewtopic.php?p=7932896#p7932896
Branding - only one co-author is allowed per proposal viewtopic.php?p=17294290#p17294290
Branding - submitting nation may not advertise for a region or group viewtopic.php?p=19353563#p19353563
Branding - using an acronym or acrostic to brand a resolution's text viewtopic.php?p=2816670#p2816670
Branding - using an acronym or acrostic to brand a resolution's text viewtopic.php?p=9704879#p9704879

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:55 am

Proposal Language:

Advice - Be precise in wording viewtopic.php?p=1651698#p1651698

Definitions - do not use dictionary definitions in your proposal viewtopic.php?p=16888281#p16888281
Definitions - paraphrased dictionary definitions are allowed viewtopic.php?p=16888932#p16888932

Format - Languages other than English (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=1994662#p1994662

Illegal due to loopholes viewtopic.php?p=1441077#p1441077

Proposals that are non-species specific - Resolution #114 viewtopic.php?p=4163245#p4163245

Proposal Title challenge (denied) - Resolution #286 viewtopic.php?p=18848108#p18848108
Proposal Titles - Latin titles (provided translation matches content) are allowed viewtopic.php?p=6401043#p6401043
Proposal Titles - Title must tie to content, but some latitude is given to the author viewtopic.php?p=18848108#p18848108

Real World Violations - Names of months and days of the week (legal) viewtopic.php?p=2328863#p2328863
Real World Violations - Religion names viewtopic.php?p=1210525#p1210525

Redefining terms from previous resolutions (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3510890#p3510890

Resolution Terminology - references to humans also apply to other species viewtopic.php?p=4711929#p4711929

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:57 am

Repeals, House of Cards, and Blockers:

Amendments - illegal; only legal as repeal and replace effort viewtopic.php?p=18735356#p18735356
Amendments - why they are illegal (Ard's take) viewtopic.php?p=5705474#p5705474
Amendments - why they are illegal (Fris's treatise) viewtopic.php?p=195#p195

Passed Resolutions are legal viewtopic.php?p=281455#p281455

Repealing without NatSov (etc.) arguments - Resolution #15 viewtopic.php?p=5980630#p5980630
Repealing without NatSov (etc.) arguments - Resolution #15 viewtopic.php?p=8511129#p8511129
Repeals - arguments on the basis of faulty language viewtopic.php?p=3733541#p3733541
Repeals - Cannot legislate in a repeal viewtopic.php?p=5516694#p5516694
Repeals - Cannot legislate in a repeal viewtopic.php?p=9080219#p9080219
Repeals - explicit arguments of Duplication are illegal viewtopic.php?p=17785560#p17785560
Repeals - Honest Mistakes rule (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=3721712#p3721712
Repeals - Honest Mistake rule (affirmative) viewtopic.php?p=6409821#p6409821
Repeals - Honest Mistakes rule (denied) - Resolution #195 viewtopic.php?p=9081425#p9081425
Repeals - Honest Mistakes rule (denied) viewtopic.php?p=9081425#p9081425
Repeals - Moral and Religious sovereignty only arguments make repeals illegal viewtopic.php?p=8511129#p8511129
Repeals - sample arguments (both legal and illegal) viewtopic.php?p=16133829#p16133829
Repeals - Solely NatSov Arguments make repeals illegal viewtopic.php?p=5980630#p5980630
Repeals - tips for framing repeal arguments viewtopic.php?p=3724515#p3724515
Repeals - why the NatSov argument rule exists viewtopic.php?p=8486665#p8486665

Repeals - "it's not defined" equates with a NatSov argument viewtopic.php?p=17028873#p17028873

House of Cards - Committee usage/expansion is legal viewtopic.php?p=17465521#p17465521
House of Cards - does not apply for repeals viewtopic.php?p=5484214#p5484214
House of Cards - origin of the rule viewtopic.php?p=280813#p280813

Illegal blocker proposal (Category - Social Justice) viewtopic.php?p=7199905#p7199905
Illegal blocker proposal viewtopic.php?p=5750199#p5750199
Blocker - Resolution - analysis viewtopic.php?p=8241788#p8241788

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:58 am

The WA Itself:

WA Army-ish - authorizing a proxy force into other WA nations (illegal) viewtopic.php?p=5348977#p5348977
WA Army - why we can't have one viewtopic.php?p=14857919#p14857919
WA Military - Peacekeepers = WA Army viewtopic.php?p=3648694#p3648694

Funding the GA - Resolution #17 viewtopic.php?p=14853242#p14853242
Funding the WA - viewtopic.php?p=14853242#p14853242

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 5:59 am

Moderation

RP Behavior - Puppeteering and Accusations therein viewtopic.php?p=3511241#p3511241

When to request a legality check (hint - talk with the forum regulars first) viewtopic.php?p=8410671#p8410671
When to request a legality check (hint - talk with the forum regulars first) viewtopic.php?p=8578800#p8578800

Contacting GA Mods - don't do it via TG viewtopic.php?p=6410913#p6410913

Legality Query - scope of moderation rulings viewtopic.php?p=1419738#p1419738

by **The Dourian Embassy** » Sun Apr 20, 2014 6:00 am

Uncategorized:
Abortion
Abortion Discussion - Resolution #29 viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Abortion Discussion - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Abortion Discussion - Resolution #114 viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Abortion Discussion - Resolution #128 viewtopic.php?p=12753466#p12753466
Abortion Discussion - Analysis - Resolution #128 viewtopic.php?p=8621656#p8621656

Rights and Duties
Legislation of Ideological Bans - Resolution #2 viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Discussion - Resolution #2 viewtopic.php?p=19353563#p19353563
Compelling Practical Purpose elaboration - Resolution #35(and #2) viewtopic.php?p=4503499#p4503499

Freedom of Religion
Freedom of Religion - Resolution #27 viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Freedom of Religion - Resolution #29 viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Freedom of Religion - Resolution #30 viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087
Freedom of Religion - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=8575087#p8575087

Religious Discrimination - Resolution #35 viewtopic.php?p=5242450#p5242450

Joke Proposals

Joke Proposal (denied) - Resolution #122 viewtopic.php?p=3989224#p3989224

Multiple Topics

Ruling on various topics (pre-vote) - Resolution #99 viewtopic.php?p=1930637#p1930637

Rulings Repository

Rulings Repository

Who is online