Araraukar wrote:Separatist Peoples wrote:Could the same be done with at-vote proposals? Because, if anything, that is where the Discard hurts. One can always resubmit, but getting to voters to jump a particular way isn't always repeatable.
The way I understand it, the system would merely delay a proposal that has reached quorum for going into vote, not discarding/removing it from the queue. By the time something reaches at-vote stage, the only option to deal with a serious (found to be valid) legality challenge is the discard function.
SP's concern seems to be a repeat of Repeal GA#2, which a proposal hold would not have stopped. It seems SP wants a "vote hold" or something that keeps a resolution at bote longer until legality ruling have been worked out.