[DRAFT] Repeal "Clean Prostitute Act"

[Kitsco]

Description: Repeal the resolution #179 Clean Prostitute Act.

Noting: That this topic is still a back and forth debate over right and wrong. Addressing the opinions of those who deem that prostitution is a unmoral means of employment.

Realizing, that legalization of or legalization left to a members nation in irresponsible due to the probability of an increase in sex trafficking where prostitution is a legal means of employment.

Also, realizing that many prostitutes may be forced or forced “protection” by gang members who control the streets. These thugs you create indentured servants out of these young prostitutes through their bodies. Using these young people for money, sex and drug trafficking.

Deciding,to restore dignity to Female and Male Prostitutes and moral decency to member nations.

Require Member States to take broader action against Prostitution.

Members of the World Assembly.

For the protection and moral decency of prostitutes, not just against Sexual Transmitted Diseases, but against other humanitarian crimes.

Hereby repeals #179 Clean Prostitute Act.

[District XIV]

I'd suggest reading some past resolutions in the 'Passed World Assembly Resolutions' thread at the top of this forum, because this isn't exactly how a repeal or any GA resolution is formatted.

Please repeal the the resolution #179 Clean Prostitute Act.

Illegal for no operative clause. Get rid of the "Please" and change "repeal the the resolution" to "Hereby repeals". Which will turn into something legal:

Hereby repeals #179 Clean Prostitute Act.

[Kitsco]

Alright I rewrote the last sentence as you suggested, thanks!

[Lexicor]

I would oppose WA Meddling with this thorny issue and wish to see Clean Prostitute Act stand.

[Kitsco]

I would oppose WA Meddling with this thorny issue and wish to see Clean Prostitute Act stand.

The Clean Prostitute act does not account for the other problems that come with Legal Prostitution, I would only like to see the Clean Prostitute Act Repealed to make way for a more, defining resolution that protects Prostitutes.

But this Resolution must be repealed in my opinion.

[Defwa]

You cannot legislate in a repeal. That is to say you can't make anybody do anything in the repeal.
And you complaints aren't really backed up. A well regulated sex market reduces the need for sexual trafficking. Issues with gangs are not something CPA could deal with because its a totally different subject but there's nothing stopping you from drafting a resolution that protects against that.

[Lumeau]

Addressing the opinions of those who deem that prostitution is a unmoral means of employment.

What?

Realizing, that legalization of or legalization left to a members nation in irresponsible due to the probability of an increase in sex trafficking where prostitution is a legal means of employment.

Sex trafficking is a problem largely caused by the fact that prostitution is ILLEGAL in many places. Laws against it keep clean, safe, well-regulated prostitution businesses from operating. Also, fix your grammar.

Require Member States to take broader action against Prostitution.

Repeal resolutions cannot do anything except repeal. They can't require WA members to do anything. The entire resolution is illegal under WA law for this reason.

This resolution is a complete mess. The grammar makes it borderline incoherent and it fundamentally misunderstands the causes of sex trafficking.

Against. Also, this has no hope of passing or even reaching quorum, at least in its current form.

--The Executive-General of the Commonwealth of Lumeau

[Point Breeze]

I'd advise you to read some previous repeals to get a sense of how they attack a resolution and develop an argument against it. Also, as others have stated, your proposal is illegal for attempting to legislate in a repeal. Repeal legislations can only accomplish one task. The rest must come from the replacement legislation.

[Normlpeople]

"Do keep in mind that there is a large contingent here that will agree with you, since they wish to see a WA legalization on prostitution. This may well backfire in your face. That said, as it is written, there is nothing stopping you from outlawing it within your borders. We see the actions of two consenting adults behind closed doors unworthy of such a ban"