Gregoryisgodistan wrote:I would add "distinct from the giving nation" to iii to allow for an NS equivalent of Germany splitting and reunifying. Saintland is currently undergoing such a split, and if it reunified in the future, it would make sense for Saintland to take back West Saintland's rank as Germany did with West Germany.
This is a good point. I think it might be easier simply to remove the 'has ever had' part of section iii. Anyone trying to operate outwith the spirit of the law would be caught by section ii. I've also removed the 'many' typo from the second sentence.
3.2 Exchanging of ranking points between nations
A nation's KPB points are the property of the nation, not the user. A user may only transfer the ranking points from one nation to another provided that both of the following criteria are met:
i) The nation receiving the ranking points offers clear and direct in-character continuity between the previous nation and the new nation.
ii) The transfer of ranking points is approved by both the WCC President and Vice President (who may choose to consult with the WCC before reaching a decision).
A nation may not receive another nation's KPB points if:
iii) The receiving nation already has a KPB rank.
iv) The receiving nation is controlled by a different user.