Advertisement
by Bubba Reb » Mon Apr 27, 2015 9:23 pm
by Lyncanestria » Mon Apr 27, 2015 10:31 pm
Bubba Reb wrote:If you have ever known an American, native southerner, you will know the second is far less realistic than the first.
: Vehicular accident kills 3, including Fleury CF striker :: Burgoyard seperatist demonstrations turn violent in Jugny :: After a term out of office, Mariard regains Premiership :: Emperor undertakes official visit to Vannois :: Baudelaire Systems unveil newest phone, the Astro 4 :: Moulins declares Caeseti regime "illegitimate" :
by Cestyr » Tue Apr 28, 2015 12:09 am
by Bubba Reb » Tue Apr 28, 2015 12:23 am
by Bubba Reb » Tue Apr 28, 2015 12:33 am
Cestyr wrote:Ten million is a more reasonable figure than 25 million, but it's still an insane amount of people to have settled in 16 years time into a place where you're starting with literally nothing. Moving that amount of people in could technically be done, but realistically you'd be looking at a nation with the social order of a very large refugee camp albeit with more luxury. The saying "Rome wasn't built in a day" has never been more apt in a discussion which I've been in; there's much more to building a nation than building a house for everybody to live in. As a project engineer working in civil construction, I've known that even the most basic, menial things can take a year to complete and cost millions while some of the larger projects, like highways and hospitals, can be ten year propositions. Again, you could theoretically but it's not realistic. And then there's a lot more to building a nation than just building things as well, like having jobs for the immigrants when they get off the boat. The problem people have when moving into a new sub-development or pop-up suburb is always the access to employment because it's initially non-existent, and people without jobs don't have a great deal to spend. It's partially the reason why China is able to build dozens of empty apartment buildings in ghost cities that don't have anybody to live there; they have nothing to move there for.
That aside, I think you're being a little overzealous in your estimates and I think your application would work much better if you roleplayed as a man who built his own Monaco or Cayman Islands rather than a man who built his own Australia. That'd also give you a quite unique standing in the region and make for some very interesting relationships between other nations. Ultimately, you have the final say on what you submit to the region, but I still feel that some of the "coolness" of your concept is lost by attempting to be very young, large and developed nation all at the same time. If you're concerned about regional influence, I doubt you'd lose any by going down to a much smaller nation if you can still carve a niche out for yourself as a haven for the rich and famous.
by Cestyr » Tue Apr 28, 2015 1:42 am
Bubba Reb wrote:Cestyr wrote:Ten million is a more reasonable figure than 25 million, but it's still an insane amount of people to have settled in 16 years time into a place where you're starting with literally nothing. Moving that amount of people in could technically be done, but realistically you'd be looking at a nation with the social order of a very large refugee camp albeit with more luxury. The saying "Rome wasn't built in a day" has never been more apt in a discussion which I've been in; there's much more to building a nation than building a house for everybody to live in. As a project engineer working in civil construction, I've known that even the most basic, menial things can take a year to complete and cost millions while some of the larger projects, like highways and hospitals, can be ten year propositions. Again, you could theoretically but it's not realistic. And then there's a lot more to building a nation than just building things as well, like having jobs for the immigrants when they get off the boat. The problem people have when moving into a new sub-development or pop-up suburb is always the access to employment because it's initially non-existent, and people without jobs don't have a great deal to spend. It's partially the reason why China is able to build dozens of empty apartment buildings in ghost cities that don't have anybody to live there; they have nothing to move there for.
That aside, I think you're being a little overzealous in your estimates and I think your application would work much better if you roleplayed as a man who built his own Monaco or Cayman Islands rather than a man who built his own Australia. That'd also give you a quite unique standing in the region and make for some very interesting relationships between other nations. Ultimately, you have the final say on what you submit to the region, but I still feel that some of the "coolness" of your concept is lost by attempting to be very young, large and developed nation all at the same time. If you're concerned about regional influence, I doubt you'd lose any by going down to a much smaller nation if you can still carve a niche out for yourself as a haven for the rich and famous.
As I've said several times, the numbers mean little to me. I've cut them to 1/4 of what they were.
I can even adjust Bubba Rebs age to ....46 or even 51, thus giving the nation a 31 year history instead of 16. But it really seems that for some, especially those who have not talked with me or read my RPs and history, that the numbers are irrelevant. That I could agree to one hundred people living in a tent, with a canoe for their military, and they would still find reasons to oppose it.
If that turns out to be the case, then I will just move on.
by Mizuyuki » Tue Apr 28, 2015 1:48 am
Bubba Reb wrote:Now for the argument against my acceptance to devolve into a criticism of accents in RP and a few typos..... I dunno.
I'm starting to consider withdrawing my application.
by Winpheala » Tue Apr 28, 2015 2:23 am
Cestyr wrote:b]Winpheala[/b], I'm leaning towards a yes, but first I'd like to give you a writing prompt so we can get a better idea of your RP. The setting is the arrival of your delegate/delegation at an international conference between several Aenean nations regarding illegal trout fishing. Take a few days if you need to.
by Viridisolum » Tue Apr 28, 2015 3:01 am
by Mizuyuki » Tue Apr 28, 2015 3:18 am
Winpheala wrote:I deeply apologise for the time it took for me to reply to this, but I'm afraid there's no way I can RP that due to my nation's current state. If you want however, I'm currently doing a P2TM RP and I'll link you my post when I've made one.
by Insaeldor » Tue Apr 28, 2015 3:22 am
by Bubba Reb » Tue Apr 28, 2015 9:00 am
Insaeldor wrote:If I may put in my though on the Bubba Reb discussion, I'm very conflicted. While I've seen a very goofy style come from him that is refreshing it simply doesn't really fit the way I have seen others RP here. Not because it's bad but because it's a very silly boarderline satirical style that doesn't really convay seriousness. That really my only issue with Bubba and as long as he can get the numbers worked out as he said he's been willing to do and maybe give an example of a more serious sounding RP I'd more than happy to see him aboard.
by Winpheala » Tue Apr 28, 2015 9:09 am
Mizuyuki wrote:Winpheala wrote:I deeply apologise for the time it took for me to reply to this, but I'm afraid there's no way I can RP that due to my nation's current state. If you want however, I'm currently doing a P2TM RP and I'll link you my post when I've made one.
Yes, that should be good enough for us. Take all the time you need; we're not going anywhere in a hurry.
by North Defese » Tue Apr 28, 2015 1:19 pm
by Ghant » Tue Apr 28, 2015 2:30 pm
by Lyncanestria » Wed Apr 29, 2015 8:59 am
: Vehicular accident kills 3, including Fleury CF striker :: Burgoyard seperatist demonstrations turn violent in Jugny :: After a term out of office, Mariard regains Premiership :: Emperor undertakes official visit to Vannois :: Baudelaire Systems unveil newest phone, the Astro 4 :: Moulins declares Caeseti regime "illegitimate" :
by Bubba Reb » Wed Apr 29, 2015 10:27 am
Lyncanestria wrote:Okay Bubba Reb, here is my verdict, copied from our regional RMB:
- Right now, as your latest application currently stands, I am going for a nay.
- It will change to an abstention once your figures are solidified to a couple thousand in population at maximum, given your current history, submitted with your latest application.
- My ruling has the potential to become an aye if you were to completely rework your numbers and history to sufficiently:
(a) reflect a more plausible timeframe for a working country propped from scratch to become sufficient;
(b) provide a more realistic account for the population growth in his country apart from "Bubba had friends";
(c) give an explanation on why any self-respecting nation would allow for privately-held property in their territory to secede because "they feel like it";
(d) lower your IC stats as stated in the above bullet point;
(e) consider the possibility of RPing with a different country name--I won't hold it against you, but I'll be more willing to support your application if you'd be open to the proposition of existing ICly under a country name that's not the same as their dictatorial leader, not even a deranged Hitler renamed Germany to Hitlerland.
by Ghant » Wed Apr 29, 2015 10:41 am
Bubba Reb wrote:Lyncanestria wrote:Okay Bubba Reb, here is my verdict, copied from our regional RMB:
- Right now, as your latest application currently stands, I am going for a nay.
- It will change to an abstention once your figures are solidified to a couple thousand in population at maximum, given your current history, submitted with your latest application.
- My ruling has the potential to become an aye if you were to completely rework your numbers and history to sufficiently:
(a) reflect a more plausible timeframe for a working country propped from scratch to become sufficient;
(b) provide a more realistic account for the population growth in his country apart from "Bubba had friends";
(c) give an explanation on why any self-respecting nation would allow for privately-held property in their territory to secede because "they feel like it";
(d) lower your IC stats as stated in the above bullet point;
(e) consider the possibility of RPing with a different country name--I won't hold it against you, but I'll be more willing to support your application if you'd be open to the proposition of existing ICly under a country name that's not the same as their dictatorial leader, not even a deranged Hitler renamed Germany to Hitlerland.
So basically you are saying you expect me to create a new nation with a different history, different name, no more than 2000 population, and practically provide real life examples that mirror the nations founding, government, culture and story.
While I have adapted, reduced, complied, and compromised probably more than any applicant to the region has ever been willing to do.....
I hearby withdraw my application to Aeneas.
Thank you Defense for your warm welcome and support, for going above and beyond to try to help me make this happen.
To everyone else who spent the time to consult, and chat with me, and/or showed support for my acceptance, Thank you. You were a great help.
Perhaps in the future we can meet in RPs and write together. That would be nice.
by Nasiristan » Wed Apr 29, 2015 10:49 am
Ghant wrote:Bubba Reb wrote:
So basically you are saying you expect me to create a new nation with a different history, different name, no more than 2000 population, and practically provide real life examples that mirror the nations founding, government, culture and story.
While I have adapted, reduced, complied, and compromised probably more than any applicant to the region has ever been willing to do.....
I hearby withdraw my application to Aeneas.
Thank you Defense for your warm welcome and support, for going above and beyond to try to help me make this happen.
To everyone else who spent the time to consult, and chat with me, and/or showed support for my acceptance, Thank you. You were a great help.
Perhaps in the future we can meet in RPs and write together. That would be nice.
Withdrawing your application because of one guy being opposed seems a bit brash, don't you think? You seem to have the support of the vast majority of people in the region, and for me that is enough.
by Otulia » Wed Apr 29, 2015 10:59 am
by Lyncanestria » Wed Apr 29, 2015 11:09 am
Bubba Reb wrote:So basically you are saying you expect me to create a new nation with a different history, different name, no more than 2000 population, and practically provide real life examples that mirror the nations founding, government, culture and story.
Bubba Reb wrote:While I have adapted, reduced, complied, and compromised probably more than any applicant to the region has ever been willing to do.....
Bubba Reb wrote:Thank youDefenseDefese for your warm welcome and support, for going above and beyond to try to help me make this happen.
To everyone else who spent the time to consult, and chat with me, and/or showed support for my acceptance, Thank you. You were a great help.
Perhaps in the future we can meet in RPs and write together. That would be nice.
: Vehicular accident kills 3, including Fleury CF striker :: Burgoyard seperatist demonstrations turn violent in Jugny :: After a term out of office, Mariard regains Premiership :: Emperor undertakes official visit to Vannois :: Baudelaire Systems unveil newest phone, the Astro 4 :: Moulins declares Caeseti regime "illegitimate" :
by Ghant » Wed Apr 29, 2015 11:17 am
Otulia wrote:Two. Nonetheless, it's an overwhelming majority, at least two-thirds in favor, if not more.
I say we allow Bubba Reb in.
Advertisement
Return to Factbooks and National Information
Users browsing this forum: Cossack Peoples
Advertisement