NationStates

CTALNH wrote:I must tell you that I am a Stalinist and yes I actually like the idea of purging the Right in gulags and and traitors to the state and every other lowlife

Ok well you should probably be aware that "traitors to the state" is the same thing as "people who disagree with the ruling elite." Furthermore, purging people with 'undesirable' political beliefs won't rid you of those beliefs - it will simply drive them underground and foster violence and unrest.

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:Except that capitalism worked for a couple more millenniums then Communism.

Other way round. Communism has been humanity's modus operandi for tens of thousands of years. The earliest possible opportunity for organised capitalism occurred after the formation of large, sedentary, agricultural settlements, which began appearing around 10,000 years ago. Even with the very optimistic assumption that we've been using capitalism for as long as physically possible, communism outlasts it four times over.

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:

Tubbsalot wrote:Er, communism has just as much application as capitalism. They are in fact applied to the exact same thing. Communism essentially refers to common ownership of the means of production, rather than privately-controlled market-based corporations and such.


True, but it's still crazy.

Except that capitalism worked for a couple more millenniums then Communism.

It hasn't really been around that long.

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:Except that capitalism worked for a couple more millenniums then Communism.

Capitalism hasn't been around that long, IIRC.

Jusela wrote:

CTALNH wrote:That's Why I am a Stalinist you make people like it were they want it or not at gunpoint of course.

Your parents didn't love you enough, did they?

Actually they did love me and I must say my dad is very proud of me because I am a communist at heart I don't know why but he keeps telling me that I am a anarcho communist

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:

Jusela wrote:
Well, excuse me for double posting, but how do you define "traitors" and "lowlifes"? Seriously, I think you're suffering from a case of narcissism.

Duh. People that aren't just like me. Ergo, they aren't perfect.
Sorry for the double post.

Except that Communism was never applied right.

Tubbsalot wrote:

CTALNH wrote:I must tell you that I am a Stalinist and yes I actually like the idea of purging the Right in gulags and and traitors to the state and every other lowlife

Ok well you should probably be aware that "traitors to the state" is the same thing as "people who disagree with the ruling elite." Furthermore, purging people with 'undesirable' political beliefs won't rid you of those beliefs - it will simply drive them underground and foster violence and unrest.

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:Except that capitalism worked for a couple more millenniums then Communism.

Other way round. Communism has been humanity's modus operandi for tens of thousands of years. The earliest possible opportunity for organised capitalism occurred after the formation of large, sedentary, agricultural settlements, which began appearing around 10,000 years ago. Even with the very optimistic assumption that we've been using capitalism for as long as physically possible, communism outlasts it four times over.

No actually I mean spies

Grammar. On NSG it's a dream.

Revisionist Trotskyite just popping in here to say that Stalin was a complete madman, and Stalinism is no better than fascism with a red banner.

CTALNH wrote:No actually I mean spies

Not if you're a Stalinist, you don't. If an unaccountable government has access to powers like that, they will inevitably be abused by the individuals of that government. If you really like Stalinism you'll have to get used to corruption like that.

Georgism wrote:

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:Except that capitalism worked for a couple more millenniums then Communism.

Capitalism hasn't been around that long, IIRC.

Depends. Certain ancient cultures had aspects of it.

Tubbsalot wrote:

CTALNH wrote:No actually I mean spies

Not if you're a Stalinist, you don't. If an unaccountable government has access to powers like that, they will inevitably be abused by the individuals of that government. If you really like Stalinism you'll have to get used to corruption like that.

Actually the best way to make the people want to kill someone is to charge him that he is a spy

Sibirsky wrote:

Georgism wrote:Capitalism hasn't been around that long, IIRC.

Depends. Certain ancient cultures had aspects of it.

Got to Agree with what he says the Ancient Greek culture had it

Moresnetujo wrote:Revisionist Trotskyite just popping in here to say that Stalin was a complete madman, and Stalinism is no better than fascism with a red banner.

Well if he was explain why 70% of the Russians would like him back

CTALNH wrote:Actually the best way to make the people want to kill someone is to charge him that he is a spy

I have no doubt that accused spies would be put to death pretty quickly in a reincarnated USSR. A lot of innocent people would die as well, though.

CTALNH wrote:

Moresnetujo wrote:Revisionist Trotskyite just popping in here to say that Stalin was a complete madman, and Stalinism is no better than fascism with a red banner.

Well if he was explain why 70% of the Russians would like him back

Because they have a nostalgic view of him. It's not based on reality.

CTALNH wrote:I must tell you that I am a Stalinist and yes I actually like the idea of purging the Right in gulags and and traitors to the state and every other lowlife

*SIGH*

Please stop making Pro-Staliners look bad. Stalinism isn't a tenancy of Communism, it's a derogatory term agaisnt Marxist-Leninists that ultra-leftists and trots made and use.

I can help you be taken seriously by everyone else if you'd just stop talking about things you have little knowledge of, comrade. As Mao said: "No investigation, no right to speak!"

CTALNH wrote:

Moresnetujo wrote:Revisionist Trotskyite just popping in here to say that Stalin was a complete madman, and Stalinism is no better than fascism with a red banner.

Well if he was explain why 70% of the Russians would like him back

The poll you're thinking of showed that just under 70% of Russians wanted the return of the Soviet Union. In reality, the number who want Stalin back is about 15%.

Sibirsky wrote:

CTALNH wrote:Well if he was explain why 70% of the Russians would like him back

Because they have a nostalgic view of him. It's not based on reality.

You sure about that?

Moresnetujo wrote:

CTALNH wrote:Well if he was explain why 70% of the Russians would like him back

The poll you're thinking of showed that just under 70% of Russians wanted the return of the Soviet Union. In reality, the number who want Stalin back is about 15%.

Nope

CTALNH wrote:

Sibirsky wrote:Because they have a nostalgic view of him. It's not based on reality.

You sure about that?

Yes, I'm sure.

Stalin sent millions to gulags for petty crimes. Some of them for being dissidents. For making a joke about the government or for writing a book he did not agree with. Millions more died. Only an idiot would want to return to that totalitarian hellhole.

CTALNH wrote:

Moresnetujo wrote:
The poll you're thinking of showed that just under 70% of Russians wanted the return of the Soviet Union. In reality, the number who want Stalin back is about 15%.

Nope

If Stalin's so popular in Russia, explain why the KPRF (the only major pro-Stalin party in Russia) isn't cleaning up in elections.

Moresnetujo wrote:

CTALNH wrote:Nope

If Stalin's so popular in Russia, explain why the KPRF (the only major pro-Stalin party in Russia) isn't cleaning up in elections.

You are asking me to explain the unexplained!

Communism is both unobtainable in society at large and undesirable.

CTALNH wrote:

Moresnetujo wrote:Revisionist Trotskyite just popping in here to say that Stalin was a complete madman, and Stalinism is no better than fascism with a red banner.

Well if he was explain why 70% of the Russians would like him back

I assume- if that statistic is true- because he saved them from the Nazis and bombarded his people with 29 years' worth of propaganda.

Simon Cowell of the RR wrote:I still do not understand why communism is so popular.

Communism is so popular because of having a classless state. Most of the people who are workers and being oppressed by the rich people want an equal rights, cause some people can be bought by money. Karl Marx dream of an equal society where there is no rich or poor but people with the same states. Technically, it can happen, but its just Stalin who changed the dream of an classless state into a hideous ideology which people consider a threat and full of scumbags.

CTALNH wrote:

Moresnetujo wrote:
If Stalin's so popular in Russia, explain why the KPRF (the only major pro-Stalin party in Russia) isn't cleaning up in elections.

You are asking me to explain the unexplained!

Yes, I am. If Stalin really is that popular, Yedinaja Rossija shouldn't have such a grip on power.