Should india ban all pakistani films and artists

[Luziyca]

No. /endof

[Amuaplye]

Who is this "Mr. Jinnah"?

I am sorry but this is the most ignorant thing I have ever heard, please google jinnah, this is extremely ignorant of you

I'm not ignorant. Besides, it's not Jinnah's fault, it's groups like Al Qaeda's fault.

[Benuty]

No. /endof

If only it were ever that simple.

[Geilinor]

The constitution does not recognize any official priviledges, and to answer your question, it depends upon the social standings, which vary from community to community just like in hindus

The US Constitution is officially secular but Christians here are privileged and they enact their religious will on secular law often.

So the US is not a secular country either?

[Dyakovo]

No-one outside of the Indian subcontinent (except historians) has any reason to know who he is.

Than no need to come in thread where such knowledge is basic requirement to join

You not only profess ignorance but celebrate it

You amuse me. I identified who he was in my post prior to the one you responded to. Face it, to most of the world, he just isn't very important. I'm certain you couldn't name the founders and/or first rulers in most South American countries.
Also, I already said that if you're taking part in a discussion of Pakistan, you should bone-up on at least the highlights of their history.

[Dyakovo]

9th grade was 30 years ago.

So Dya, what were the dinosaurs like?

Quite fun to ride.
*nods*

[Pineville Community]

I ain't never seen any indian or pakistani films to my knowledge
ya'll got any good recs?

I was disappointed when I learned that all the Indian movies I had seen were actually American/British.

[Kubra]

I ain't never seen any indian or pakistani films to my knowledge
ya'll got any good recs?

I was disappointed when I learned that all the Indian movies I had seen were actually American/British.

For my part it's always brits
like you think you're seeing an international film but somehow unless it's black and white a brit directed it

[West Aurelia]

No.

[Nightkill the Emperor]

No. /endof

If only it were ever that simple.

In this case it pretty much is.

[Aryavartha]

err...what is the point of such topics here..

most people here couldn't care any less about india pak issues. pretty much everybody is ignorant of the region and their views can be summed up as 'well hope they don't nuke each other', 'pakistan jihadis', 'india rapists'. thats about it.

no, india should not ban paki artists. the govt should have no role in who acts in what films whatever.

actually it should give visas and asylum to genuinely talented pakiland artists. pakistanis want more islam. the dry wahabi variety. music dance etc are haraam.

[Korouse]

Manisdog was reincarnated.

No, India should not be banning Pakistani films left and right.

[Napkiraly]

No.

[Napkiraly]

Bollywood isn't that good either.

Yeah the Bollywood films ive seen have been pretty shit.

Or just flat out random as fuck... which im still trying to decide is good or bad.

Anyway no India should not ban them.

Satya is actually a pretty good film imo. A good noirish crime film.

But yeah generally speaking Bollywood films are pretty bad or just....I dunno.

[The Huskar Social Union]

Yeah the Bollywood films ive seen have been pretty shit.

Or just flat out random as fuck... which im still trying to decide is good or bad.

Anyway no India should not ban them.

Satya is actually a pretty good film imo. A good noirish crime film.

But yeah generally speaking Bollywood films are pretty bad or just....I dunno.

The last one i watched, was about these two thieves, who were rivals, but at the same time in love, and there was a pair of cops, in fact i think one of them was actually one of the thieves, and there was a random break out into song segment on the beach... just i dont know.


Also this thread is still going on? Really?

[Infected Mushroom]

Yes.

Since Pakistan has banned Indian films and artists, India is justified in retaliating.

If India retaliates, it will show Pakistan's leaders that India will not take such nonsense. If Pakistan ban India movies... India ban Pakistan movies. If Pakistan play rough, India play rough.

''If you un-ban them, we'll un-ban them. If you ban. we ban. What you ban we will ban over a thousand fold.''

Pakistan's leaders have two choices with regards to this issue. They can keep India's movies banned, or they can realise the costs. India's response should be this:

''Ban the films. Ban the artists. Show them what it means to choose the wrong side.''

[New Carloso]

Yes.

Since Pakistan has banned Indian films and artists, India is justified in retaliating.

If India retaliates, it will show Pakistan's leaders that India will not take such nonsense. If Pakistan ban India movies... India ban Pakistan movies. If Pakistan play rough, India play rough.

''If you un-ban them, we'll un-ban them. If you ban. we ban. What you ban we will ban over a thousand fold.''

Pakistan's leaders have two choices with regards to this issue. They can keep India's movies banned, or they can realise the costs. India's response should be this:

''Ban the films. Ban the artists. Show them what it means to choose the wrong side.''

"An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind." - Gandhi

[Kusengard]

[The Third Nova Terra of Scrin]

err...what is the point of such topics here..

most people here couldn't care any less about india pak issues. pretty much everybody is ignorant of the region and their views can be summed up as 'well hope they don't nuke each other', 'pakistan jihadis', 'india rapists'. thats about it.

no, india should not ban paki artists. the govt should have no role in who acts in what films whatever.

actually it should give visas and asylum to genuinely talented pakiland artists. pakistanis want more islam. the dry wahabi variety. music dance etc are haraam.

This - The OP should do better asking fellow Indians or other Pakistanis than shove down the topic to fellow Western NSers, who know nothing about the topic whatsoever. I'm amused that everybody says "no" yet actually knows nothing about the obscure issue in question.

By the way, nations in conflict have a tendency to ban the rival nation's entertainment and popular culture. Remember that the broadcasting of Japanese music and television is still banned in South Korea, right? I could see why the Indian government would like to ban the Pakistani film industry and its artists. Also, considering that it was Pakistan first that banned Indian films at the first place.

[Naushantiya]

Yes.

Since Pakistan has banned Indian films and artists, India is justified in retaliating.

If India retaliates, it will show Pakistan's leaders that India will not take such nonsense. If Pakistan ban India movies... India ban Pakistan movies. If Pakistan play rough, India play rough.

''If you un-ban them, we'll un-ban them. If you ban. we ban. What you ban we will ban over a thousand fold.''

Pakistan's leaders have two choices with regards to this issue. They can keep India's movies banned, or they can realise the costs. India's response should be this:

''Ban the films. Ban the artists. Show them what it means to choose the wrong side.''

This post is awesome

[The Third Nova Terra of Scrin]

Yes.

Since Pakistan has banned Indian films and artists, India is justified in retaliating.

If India retaliates, it will show Pakistan's leaders that India will not take such nonsense. If Pakistan ban India movies... India ban Pakistan movies. If Pakistan play rough, India play rough.

''If you un-ban them, we'll un-ban them. If you ban. we ban. What you ban we will ban over a thousand fold.''

Pakistan's leaders have two choices with regards to this issue. They can keep India's movies banned, or they can realise the costs. India's response should be this:

''Ban the films. Ban the artists. Show them what it means to choose the wrong side.''

Lol, start a South Asian entertainment and pop culture war.

[Naushantiya]

err...what is the point of such topics here..

most people here couldn't care any less about india pak issues. pretty much everybody is ignorant of the region and their views can be summed up as 'well hope they don't nuke each other', 'pakistan jihadis', 'india rapists'. thats about it.

no, india should not ban paki artists. the govt should have no role in who acts in what films whatever.

actually it should give visas and asylum to genuinely talented pakiland artists. pakistanis want more islam. the dry wahabi variety. music dance etc are haraam.

I am truly shocked at their ignorance, they don't know who jinnah is and I doubt they know anything, henceforth onwards I am not going to make topics on India in NSG because such a discussion is always going to be pointless


I would disagree with giving asylum and visas to talented Pakistani artists, we need to do more to promote our own artists, especially Indian theater and folk artists who are struggling. Let us help our own artists and encourage our own art and not take part in aiding people who are actually our enemies...

They got their promised land of Pakistan, now they should stay there and not come in our country. We don't need Pakistanis in India, they have their great promised muslim land made out of what was primarily our ancient land. We don't need any of them here even if they can sing a few notes or dance perfectly.

I think we should adopt a go out and stay there policy towards Pakistan

[Naushantiya]

Than no need to come in thread where such knowledge is basic requirement to join

You not only profess ignorance but celebrate it

You amuse me. I identified who he was in my post prior to the one you responded to. Face it, to most of the world, he just isn't very important. I'm certain you couldn't name the founders and/or first rulers in most South American countries.
Also, I already said that if you're taking part in a discussion of Pakistan, you should bone-up on at least the highlights of their history.

I would make an effort to educate myself first

[Kusengard]

Good, stop making India topics. Perhaps then we shall hear the last of your wildly xenophobic and absurdly distorted view of reality.

[Naushantiya]

Good, stop making India topics. Perhaps then we shall hear the last of your wildly xenophobic and absurdly distorted view of reality.

This is my first India topic and the last one