A Jewish State in Germany?

[Gideus]

I am Jewish and I don't see why this should be done; it's a stupid idea that would never work and could not be executed at a worse time considering the economy.

We already have Israel(and I still stand by the fact that it was the Arab League/Palestinian leaders' faults that Palestine was completely or nearly completely "destroyed" to make room for Israel; see the two-state partition) and we live throughout most of the Western world. Personally I see a "State" or country being established based on religion as pure silly.

[The Dalekss]

chopping up nations just because ? Well then,we should create a Romanian state in Germany (because we're supposed to all be equals and since jews are allowed to do that... )
Bad idea. I am not German and I still think the retards who even proposed the idea need to face some consequences (and I don't care if they are jews or anything else )

[Leepaidamba]

They have a nation already.

It's called Israel Palestine.

In the Tenakh they were promised Israel, not Palestine.

The big problem being that they're in the same place.

[Nazi Flower Power]

I am not German and I still think the retards who even proposed the idea need to face some consequences (and I don't care if they are jews or anything else )

Why? They didn't do anything except propose a bad idea, which no one has acted on.

[The Dalekss]

I am not German and I still think the retards who even proposed the idea need to face some consequences (and I don't care if they are jews or anything else )

Why? They didn't do anything except propose a bad idea, which no one has acted on.

because they're pigs for even proposing that

[Nazi Flower Power]

Why? They didn't do anything except propose a bad idea, which no one has acted on.

because they're pigs for even proposing that

Yeah, but being pigs isn't a crime.

[Bratoslovoukia]

This is fantastic. I hope it happens.

[The Dalekss]

because they're pigs for even proposing that

Yeah, but being pigs isn't a crime.

i know,i know but if someone really pushed for it they should really face some consequences such as national treason or something like that

[Unilisia]

They have Israel and the Jewish Autonomous Oblast. The second one is more peaceful than the first

[The Dalekss]

They have Israel and the Jewish Autonomous Oblast. The second one is more peaceful than the first

why don't they just move there ? The russians did them a big favour and they don't even appreciate it

[Thanatttynia]

But what about the non-Jews that already live there??

[Zemvoray]

EDIT: Killed all that.

Point 13: This is not a realistic movement. 'Nuff said. I could have a theory about a cheese loving state in Britain, but that doesn't deserve a thread though (or does it.....).

Yes it does.

...I'd live there. ^_^

[Laobaen]

Alright, while we're at it lets turn Southern England into an independent Islamic nation, give the turks control over a piece of Germany, establish independent African, Asian, and Mexican nations within the US, divide Israel between the Palestinians, Jews, and Africans, and otherwise just divide the entire planet into small pockets of opposing religions and cultures because everyone should strive to copy the Balkans.

[Nazi Flower Power]

This is fantastic. I hope it happens.

YEAH! TO HELL WITH THE BASIC RIGHTS OF EVERYONE IN WEIMAR! JEW POWER!

Seriously, this idea isn't even popular among Jews. The Jews who think it's necessary for there to be an independent Jewish nation usually also believe that that nation is supposed to be in Israel.

[Risottia]

But what about the non-Jews that already live there??

Untermenschen, all of them.

[Malronia]

I think that the idea of a Jewish state in Germany is silly and ill-conceived.

2 >Medinat Weimar is a solution to overcome the present crises and heal Jewish trauma, German guilt....

This is basically just saying, "You guys suck so we're going to take your land"

[The Republic of Lanos]

Why can't they move to Israel?

[Risottia]

Here they go again, the Jews are making use of their Holocaust Card. I don't think Germany will fall for it, but I'll be interesting to see what happens.

Just guessing... the Germans will just ignore those little trolls, who, btw, don't seem to represent a significant fraction of the Jews - in Germany, in Israel or all around the world.

[Raumm]

They have 2 already, and that's is plenty. Western nations have anti-discrimination laws and the right to freedom of religion. There's no need to go around setting up theologian or ethnic bantustans.

[Coccygia]

It would've been a better idea than a Jewish state in Palestine (not that anybody could realize that in 1948), but it's a bit late for that now.

[The Blaatschapen]

It would've been a better idea than a Jewish state in Palestine (not that anybody could realize that in 1948), but it's a bit late for that now.

Because what the post-war Germanies needed were more displaced Germans.

[Holstria]

I don't see why it's necessary, Germany is for the Germans (citizens that is) and this would simply stir a nonexistent pot that doesn't need stirring. While some of it isn't really bad, it's still unnecessary.

[Coccygia]

It would've been a better idea than a Jewish state in Palestine (not that anybody could realize that in 1948), but it's a bit late for that now.

Because what the post-war Germanies needed were more displaced Germans.

No, because at least Germany had it coming.

[Wamitoria]

Because what the post-war Germanies needed were more displaced Germans.

No, because at least Germany had it coming.

Tbh, the displacement of Palestinians didn't really happen on a large scale until the Six-Day War, which was in '67, IIRC.